North Shore – 516-487-3420 * South Shore – 516-437-0505 * Five Towns – 516-374-1800 * Queens – 718-229-5454

Ollies Taxi News & Events

The Top Long Island Pizzerias for an Authentic New York Slice

Posted by Collin McGorty on Mar 21, 2019 9:00:00 AM

Long Island Pizzerias

When it comes to the best pizza in the United States, New York constantly takes the cake as the best of the best. However, some people aren’t aware that excellent pizza extends far beyond Manhattan, Queens and Brooklyn. In fact, in a place like Long Island, quality pizzerias are a dime a dozen. However, if you’re looking for some of the best pies in the area, these Long Island pizzerias do it like no other.

Ollie’s Favorite Long Island Pizzerias

Umberto’s of New Hyde Park

Since 1965, Umberto’s of New Hyde Park has been enthralling generations of Long Islanders with pizza crafted from the Neapolitan tradition.

Although they’re primarily known for their Grandma Pizza (which was featured on the Food Network’s “The Best Thing I Ever Ate”), Umberto’s has all kinds of amazing pies. They’ve even been voted as the Best Pizzeria on Long Island for six years, according to the Long Island Press.

Besides popular pies like Buffalo Chicken and Sicilian, they also serve plenty of other Italian favorites like pasta, antipasto, heroes and more. Therefore, if you’re looking for the quintessential Long Island pizzeria, Umberto’s of New Hyde Park is where it’s at, so click here to make a reservation.

Long Island Pizzerias


Located in the heart of Garden City village, Grimaldi’s is one of the top local destinations for authentic coal-fired pizza. That’s because Patsy Grimaldi learned everything he knows from his uncle, Patsy Lancieri, the founder of the famous Patsy’s Pizzeria in East Harlem.

When the coal-fired pizza craze began decades ago, Patsy Grimaldi decided to bring this tasty tradition to Long Island. From specialty pies like Eggplant Delight and Vodka to Chicken Parm and BBQ, this Long Island pizzeria truly has it all.

They also have calzones, salads, plenty of drink selections and a beautiful atmosphere, so make sure to stop by if you’re in the area!

Long Island Pizzerias

Village Pizza

Village Pizza is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant and pizzeria that takes pride in its authentic cuisine and Neapolitan legacy. In fact, they are well-known for combining the finest quality Italian cuisine with iconic, traditional pizza-making techniques.

At Village Pizza, they strive to utilize the freshest ingredients and recipes to craft out-of-this-world pies like Chicken Caesar, White Pizza, Margherita and so much more.

Long Island Pizzerias

Whether you’re looking for a memorable Floral Park dinner or just a quick slice, this Long Island pizzeria will leave you satisfied.

Truth be told, it’s hard to go wrong with any authentic Long Island pizzeria, but these three are among the best.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Topics: Long Island, Food&Drink, restaurants

Sign Up for our monthly newsletter, Ollie's Express!

Ollie's Express is a monthly newsletter email with travel tips, activities, events in Long Island and New York and more! Stay busy with Ollie's Express!

Subscribe to receive updates, coupons, and more!

Recent Posts